6 Best Screw Extractors of 2022

Jerry Wilson
Written by
Last update:

This is the best screw extractor guide to help you find the perfect set to get you out of a tough situation.

Screw extracting is a critical component of the DIY market and one that people need to be educated on.

Whether you want to save a friend’s broken bike, fix your watch, or remove a screw that’s stripped in a piece of furniture, screw extractors will be your best friend.

In order to find the right one for you, I’ve researched the market, and done in-depth testing on the products that you see here.

Hopefully, you’ll be educated enough to make a better informed decision about what product to buy, or your shopping list will at least be growing.

NameCategoryProduct
Neiko 04204A Hex Head Multi-Spline Screw and Bolt Extractor SetBest OverallNeiko 04204A Hex Head Multi-Spline Screw and Bolt Extractor Set
IRWIN Screw ExtractorBudget PickIRWIN Screw Extractor
RIDGID 35585 10 Screw Extractor SetUpgrade PickRIDGID 35585 10 Screw Extractor Set

1. Neiko 04204A Hex Head Multi-Spline Screw and Bolt Extractor Set

Our rating: 9 / 10

Neiko 04204A Hex Head Multi-Spline Screw and Bolt Extractor Set

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Plenty of sizes
  • Quality made
  • Lightning fast shipping … what more do you want?

The Neiko 04204A Hex Head Multi-Spline Screw and Bolt Extractor Set is a 25 piece set which comes with 1/8” to 7/8” by 1/32” increment. This is a large set that should be enough for everyone.

The quality of the product is excellent and is made of high-grade materials. The product also has a lifetime warranty. This is excellent from Neiko seeing that the product is made in China.

The Neiko 04204A Hex Head Multi-Spline Screw and Bolt Extractor Set is compactly packed in a metal box. This is an excellent feature as the different sizes that the extractors requires will be properly kept to avoid unnecessary losses.

2. RIDGID 35585 10 Screw Extractor Set

Our rating: 8 / 10

RIDGID 35585 10 Screw Extractor Set

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Includes ten different sizes
  • Precise fit for clean and accurate installation
  • Strong and sturdy construction

Extract a Stripped Screw, Remove a Broken Bolt.

The Ridgid 35585 promises to remove broken screws and bolts without the traditional bolt-removal process. Although the product might appear a little rusty (get it?), its performance is anything but.

This Rust-Oleum kit is made of solid steel and comes in a variety of sizes. The set is perfect for anyone who has a stripped bolt or needs to remove rusted parts with minimal effort.

3. IRWIN Screw Extractor

Our rating: 8 / 10

IRWIN Screw Extractor

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Budget-friendly
  • Available in different size and style
  • Both easy to use and very strong
  • Ideal for emergencies
  • Ideal for stranded motorists

Cons:

  • It’s difficult to get a grip on the screw to wrench it out.
  • Installation and removal requires some added tools.

The Irwin brand has a history of making quality tools and equipment that has changed the way the world works. Over the years, they have been associated with some of the most significant innovations and developments in the field they operate.

The Irwin 52535 is a great example of this progressiveness in excellence. The set contains 10 spiral screw extractor bits that are both easy to use and strong. The spiral screw extractor set is ideal for emergencies and stranded motorists.

The set comes with a plastic case that contains the bits, and they are stored in punched out compartments to prevent them from falling into the box and being damaged.

4. IRWIN Screw Extractor Set

Our rating: 7 / 10

IRWIN Screw Extractor Set

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Comes With A Wide Range Of Sizes
  • Use Them For Out Board Fasteners
  • Great Quality For The Price

Cons:

  • Might Not Work For Deep Tangs
  • Might Not Be A Supplement For A Drill
  • Each Shank Is Not Clearly Marked

The teardrop shape and hex shape of the tip of each extractor helps in the extraction process. The extraction can also be done through heat.

Extractor Set contains 25 tools where each one consists of 2 tips. The size 1/16 is the most used size with a 1/4 square shank. The most useful tool is 12-1/2. It has been designed only to use in hard-to-reach areas.

The size 11/32 for auger drill applications has been designed for removing square, hex and other hardware. This size screw extractor is a kind of spiral tip, which gives you different sizes if necessary.

5. Ontel SpeedOut Damaged Screw Extractor & Bolt Extractor Set

Our rating: 7 / 10

Ontel SpeedOut Damaged Screw Extractor & Bolt Extractor Set

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Variety of sizes
  • Quick & Easy To Use
  • Works Effectively To Remove Broken & Damaged Screws

Cons:

  • Plastic Kit Falls Apart
  • May Require Extra Work To Remove Fasteners

This easy-to-use kit is the best way to remove broken or damaged screws from a variety of surfaces. The kit includes eight bits, one extension shaft, two extractor pieces, and one Allen key. This is a 3-piece set that comes with a variety of screw extractors. It includes bits that are 3/32-inch, 1/8-inch, 5/32-inch, and 3/8-inch.

This set of extractors is perfect for stripping or broken screws as well and other fastening devices like bolts from wood, plastic, and metal. The set includes a damaged screw extractor with carbide spiral bit and a standard bolt extractor.

The spiralized carbide bit is perfect for removing broken or stripped screws as well as the damaged screw extractor uses a 3-piece design to get the most secure grip.

6. Alden 8440P Grabit Pro Broken Bolt and Damaged Screw Extractor 4 Piece Kit

Our rating: 6 / 10

Alden 8440P Grabit Pro Broken Bolt and Damaged Screw Extractor 4 Piece Kit

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Set of 4
  • Made of hardened, heat-treated steel
  • Capable of removing both stripped and broken screws, as well as damaged bolts
  • Universal fit
  • Brass color

The Alden 8440P Grabit Pro kit comes with four state of the art extractors that can take on the toughest of tasks in an emergency. It’s fantastic that this kit comes with four different extractors, giving you the option to take on each task with the tool that best suits the job.

The Alden 8440P Grabit Pro Kit is made for both stripped and broken screws. It’s able to grip screws and bolts up to 5/8th inch in size. An added benefit, is that the tool is suitable for both steel and stainless steel.

Another bonus that goes along with this set of screw extracting tools is that the extractors are colored brass, allowing you to see where you’re screwing in and avoiding any damage.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the best screw extractor?

There are many screw extractors on the market today. But finding the best extractor can be difficult for a few reasons. For one, it often requires you to know the size of the screw you're trying to extract. Secondly, not all the extractors are manufactured the same. Depending on where the screw is located, you'll want a different style of extractor.

You'll want to know which style will work best depending on the screw you're having issues with. If you're working on a car, truck, or other vehicle, you might want a long handled extractor that'll easily reach screws located near the pedals or engine. If you are extracting stripped screws from wood, then you will want to go with a simple but sturdy design.

Who makes the best bolt extractor set?

The truth of the matter is that there are only a handful of companies that make bolt extractors and only a couple that are worthy of attention. The two best brands that do are Hitachi and Wiha. Hitachi is more of a DIY type tool whereas Wiha makes more industrial tools.

Getting a good Wiha set is by far the best choice for most. Wiha tools have a lifetime warranty and are the best when it comes to damage control on tougher bolts.

Consider picking up both a 4 piece and 6 piece Wiha 42584 set as in a perfect world you'll only use the 4 piece set. But every now and then a 6 piece set will come in handy for harder jobs.

What is the best easy out tool?

This product has the best reviews of any product we reviewed. It has 440 reviews. It is extremely easy to use.

You simply drill the head of the broken screw flush and then extract the broken screw easily. You can use this on any metal, including aluminum.

This is one of the best options because this tool is so versatile. It can extract screws from the most unique places and you can use it for a wide variety of jobs.

What happens if a screw extractor doesn't work?

After the screw is fully screwed into the workpiece, it's secured in place by the tight grip of the threads and the friction of surfaces. If the upper half of the screw can't move, it's difficult for a screw extractor to pull it out.

In cases like this, the screw is most likely too deeply embedded. In extreme cases, the screw might be stuck in place because it warped due to heat or it is rusting on the inside. Extractors are not consistently reliable, so you can't count on them to get the job done every time.

They are also not substantial enough to keep large screws from breaking. The best they can do is to provide some extra grip for your drill bit while allowing you to exert more torque. If you have a broken screw that's in a location where drilling is not an option, then you'll need to find another solution.

Conclusion

Finding the best screw extractors is more important these days than ever before. If you find yourself with a stuck or stripped screw or bolt, then you’re going to hope that you have one of the best screw extractors at hand to remove it. Don’t purchase a set before you’ve taken a look through our reviews and at the guide below first. We have been through countless screw extractor reports to bring you the top six.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Neiko 04204A Hex Head Multi-Spline Screw and Bolt Extractor SetBest OverallNeiko 04204A Hex Head Multi-Spline Screw and Bolt Extractor Set
IRWIN Screw ExtractorBudget PickIRWIN Screw Extractor
RIDGID 35585 10 Screw Extractor SetUpgrade PickRIDGID 35585 10 Screw Extractor Set